Getting up the ladder was the hardest part of anything Andre did while he was underhill. The dark made it impossible to pick out where rungs were and he wound up waving his hands around and stubbing his fingers on the wall more than once. Things got easier when he broke down and put the hat Gravel had given him on his head rather than carrying it. This freed up one hand, which helped immensely.
He had hoped the strange gleam it emanated would also provide enough light he could see by, at least a little, but it worked out better than that. Once the hat was firmly on his head Andre found he could see dimly, though details were fuzzy. Still, it was more than enough to get him up the ladder and out of the Fair Folk’s lands.
What it didn’t tell him was where he wound up, which turned out to be wet, dark and very cold. At some point, when climbing the rungs, Andre suddenly found himself underwater, still clinging to a ladder but one that was now made of old wood worn smooth by the tides instead of hard stone. That inspired him to go up the ladder faster and a second later he broke the surface, gasping. A few rungs later Andre rolled onto a wooden pier built on stone pilings. A rough hewn grotto surrounded him, echoing with the soft slap of waves on stone, with two piers protruding into the dark chamber. An old rowboat was tied up to his pier, there was nothing on the other.
Andre paused for a moment to catch his breath and wring some of the water out of his clothes and the bundle of costumes he’d had on his back. While he worked he looked around, trying to figure out where he was. Ragi and Bella had been on their way to the Magistrate’s cells. He wasn’t sure how close Bella’s door out from underhill would get her to that goal but, by the same token, he had no idea how close he was to that goal, either.
A quick lick of his lips told him the grotto was full of salt water rather than fresh. When he was deep in his cups Mastroianni occasionally mentioned how common it was for a citadel to have a secret way in and out so a handful of people could escape sieges. Although it was a wealthy, sprawling port now, Fionni was initially built as a small fortress. Perhaps this was such a bolthole, dug deep in the foundations of the city.
The air was cold and clammy but not totally still, there was a slight draft coming in over the water and that suggested there was some outlet overhead. Andre dragged himself to his feet, collected his bundle and squelched off the pier towards land. The limited amount he could see thanks to Gravel’s hat didn’t reveal much about the space he was in. His best guess was that it was a natural chamber that had later been expanded by human hands. There was no real shoreline to speak of, the edge of the cavern came straight down to the water, but there was a narrow path cut into the wall leading upwards at a steep angle. It zigzagged up into the dark past the point where the vision Gravel’s hat granted him dissolved into a meaningless haze.
It was tempting to ignore the path and just steal the rowboat. Ever since he’d found himself underhill Andre had felt more and more out of his depth. Negotiating with Fair Folk was about as far from the life of a stagehand as he could think of. If he went even further afield to the point of infiltrating Citadel Fionni on his own he felt certain that a grim fate would befall him, if not at the hands of the city’s magistrate then certainly at the hands of Captain Borgia.
Yet he still found himself hiking up the path. Sure, the secret exit to the Citadel wasn’t likely to be guarded, that would make the secret part of things difficult to keep up. The problem was the boat. Andre had never been in a boat in his life and stealing one from the Magistrate was probably not the best way to inaugurate his sailing career. So it was probably safest to get out of there the normal way.
He made it to the second switchback when a door overhead swung open and three people bundled through.
Two of them were carrying lanterns. That gave him just enough light to tell that the third person was shorter than the other two and was moving unnaturally. That was all he had time to take in before he realized he had to get off the path. It was not an easy task.
The cavern was naturally rough and steeply sloped so as soon as he stepped off the precut path he had to move with greater care. Worse, the whole of the grotto was damp and slick, complicating footing even more. There were a few small stalagmites and natural rock piles here and there but getting to one before he was spotted without making enough noise to give himself away was a fall order.
So Andre did the next best thing. Once he got about ten feet off the path he conjured a duplicate of a plaster set piece that was painted like a rock and crouched down behind it. Then he realized his hat was probably still gleaming and he pulled it off and stuck it under the fake rock. Then he peeked out and watched the trio approach.
The two figures carrying lanterns were dressed in the livery of guardsmen and they wore sideswords at their hip. The third, somewhat unnatural looking figure was an enigma. His eyes were wrapped in bandages and he moved with an odd cadence, a cane carefully sweeping the ground in front of him and his steps came in an uneven pattern. A short step, another short step, then a long step.
Andre was more than a little accustomed to acrobatics and he’d even drilled for stage fighting with the Maestro but he’d never seen that kind of cadence before. He wasn’t sure what it was for unless it somehow helped him compensate for a seeming lack of sight. The blind man wasn’t dressed in guard colors, which was no real surprise. Guards generally needed to see. Instead he wore a deep green tunic over beige hose and heavy boots that came to his mid calf. He was wrapped in a cloak that probably matched his tunic at some point in its life but now was stained by rain and mud wherever it wasn’t faded by the sun.
With his position secured Andre had attention to spare and he realized one of the guardsmen was speaking in a low voice. “There is no chance of my petition being reconsidered, signore?”
“In time, signore, in time,” the blind man answered. “Papa Borgia does not break bread with everyone, you understand. The privilege is earned.”
“I do understand,” the guard replied. “But it seems a very hard thing to have to send a girl away from her mother so that my own can walk again.”
“I know. To speak truthfully, I support your desire. You’re a much more honorable man than many who seek the advantages of the Borgia’s gratitude.” The blind man stopped and turned to put a hand on the guard’s shoulder. He moved with eerie precision for someone who theoretically couldn’t see what he was doing. “But Grigori is a man of business. The exchange of coin and favors is what he desires and both are of little value when the entire Gulf of Lum lies between him and the city where they are kept. Right now, you have little to offer him. But I wouldn’t despair, my friend, for your captain proved his worth. I’m sure that, if you stay loyal, you will prove your own in time.”
“That’s an odd thing to say,” the second guard said.
“Why is that?” The blind man gestured as he spoke and the group started moving again.
“Well, you say the Borgias seek coin but a woman over thirty is not likely to gain you much compared to the value of a girl in the bloom of youth. Yet you want to take the older woman to him rather than the younger.”
The blind man harrumphed, clearly unimpressed with the guard. “If coin were the currency then I’d say you’re right but I assure you there is more to the exchange than that. Signore, leave the question of value to us. There are many things that are only of worth because of how secret they are, after all, and it’s not my place to question how Papa Borgia chooses to assess that. We are just here to see that the transaction takes place.”
“If it’s so important to you why don’t you take her with you now?” The second guard asked.
“The pieces are not in place yet and she is safer staying here until the ship from Renicie arrives in port.” The blind man stopped when his cane hit the first board of the docks. He held out a hand towards the guardsman in front and said, “I don’t trust my footing on this old wood. Lead me.”
“Of course, signore.”
The three men proceeded to clamber into the rowboat with a fair amount of splashing and swearing before rowing off into the grotto. Andre watched them go, frowning. He wasn’t sure what to make of what he’d overheard. Certainly the woman they were talking about spiriting off to Renicie was Sophia’s mother, Charissa, but he wasn’t sure why it was necessary. Nor did he really understand why the blind man had come and gone in such secrecy. If he was a guest of the Magistrate he should have been able to walk right into the Citadel’s main gate.
Unless he wasn’t a guest of the Magistrate.
All three men had mentioned the Borgias, a somewhat dubious house of merchants from Renicie. Andre didn’t know much about them other than that they were extremely loyal to each other. The Captain had said he was a Borgia. Perhaps he was operating on behalf of their patriarch without the knowledge or permission of the magistrate.
Or perhaps the magistrate was trying to keep the city’s councilors from knowing he had helped the Borgias. Whatever it was, it seemed to demand great secrecy of the captain and his men. Perhaps Andre could work that to his advantage.
It took longer than he liked to conjure enough oil to burn both piers, made worse by the fact that he was already tired from everything he’d done that day. But once they were burning on their own he trusted the flames would go till they reached the water line. Getting a boat up to the path without tearing it open on the rocks below would be impossible. Hopefully that would prevent the captain from moving Charissa out in secrecy, buy them a few days if Ragi couldn’t rescue her immediately.
Of course, if he didn’t want to need rescuing himself Andre figured he’d better find the others as soon as possible. So he headed back up the path once again. It was time to figure out what part of the citadel he was in.

